The Isaac Mead building has anchored the corner of Greenwich Avenue and West Putnam Avenue since 1894. Now its owner wants to tear it down, and about a dozen residents showed up to Town Hall to fight it, with dozens more sending letters of opposition before the meeting even started.

Owner New England Investment Partners filed plans in June to demolish the Tudor Revival landmark along with two adjoining buildings, replacing all three with two new four-story buildings holding ground-floor retail and 14 apartments. In its filing, the firm argued more than a century of renovations have left the structure in a state where rehabilitation is "impractical" and that rebuilding "is the only responsible path forward." No one from the company showed up to defend that argument in person on July 8.

ALSO SEE | Public gets first chance to weigh in on proposed demolition of historic Greenwich Avenue building

Opponents weren't buying it. Cheryl Moss, an RTM district chair, called the building "a very meaningful site" and warned that approving a demolition-and-replica-facade plan would set a dangerous precedent. Heather Georges of the Greenwich Historical Society said she opposes the teardown especially because no plan has even been approved for what comes next.

Planning & Zoning Chair Margarita Alban, joining by Zoom, was blunt about it. "We only see the re-build application," she said. "This is up to the community and you at this point." Under Connecticut law, the Historic District Commission's strongest move is a 90-day stay — actually blocking the demolition would likely require the state to step in under a law banning the "unreasonable destruction of landmarks of the state."

The State Historic Preservation Office has started reviewing the proposed demolition after preservationists and town leaders asked it to get involved. RTM chairman Frederick Lee confirmed Friday that SHPO notified him it's opening an investigation. In his letter urging the review, Lee argued the demolition would "permanently remove authentic nineteenth-century fabric" and strip the building of its status as a contributing resource on the National Register of Historic Places. A 1979 historic resources survey once called it "one of the most important commercial structures in Greenwich" — and the first brick building ever built in the borough.

No formal demolition application has actually been filed with the Historic District Commission yet — July 8 was only a public comment session. The redevelopment still needs several zoning variances, including relief from height limits, since the site is zoned for three stories, not four. Planning & Zoning hasn't scheduled a hearing on that yet. In the meantime, preservation staff say they plan to discuss possible incentives, including a historic overlay zone, with the property owner.